Hall of Fame Store
| Name | Team | POS | Year | ||
| Alfred Colvin | Black Panthers | QB | 1968 | ||
| Joseph Cheatem | Black Panthers | FS | 1969 | ||
| Jack Oliver | Black Panthers | WR | 1969 | ||
| Robert Humphries | Black Panthers | SS | 1972 | ||
| Jim Washington | Cincinnati Panthers | DE | 1974 | ||
| Ronald Twiddy | Cincinnati Panthers | DE | 1977 | ||
| Vincent Berry | Cincinnati Panthers | SS | 1980 | ||
| Golbert Cole | Cincinnati Panthers | WR | 1980 | ||
| Sam Lewis | Cincinnati Panthers | DB | 1980 | ||
| Robert Smitty | Cincinnati Panthers | C | 1981 | ||
| Ron Carpenter | Doc's Panthers | WR | 1981 | ||
| December Lamb | Cincinnati Jets | WR | 1981 | ||
| Steve Ward | Cincinnati Jets | FS | 1982 | ||
| Keith Slaughter | Tri-City Cats | FS | 1982 | ||
| Jeff Berry | Cincinnati Panthers | MLB | 1982 | ||
| Jerome Dean | Cincinnati Panthers | FB | 1982 | ||
| J.R. Ward | Cincinnati Jets | DT | 1982 | ||
| David Jefferys | Cincinnati Jets | RB | 1982 | ||
| Mike Watson | Cincinnati Jets | FB | 1983 | ||
| James Bettis | Doc's Panthers | HB | 1983 | ||
| Gary Crumb | Cincinnati Jets | MLB | 1983 | ||
| Mtch Mayes | Tri-City Cats | WR | 1983 | ||
| Berry Bedford | Cincinnati Falcons | DE | 1983 | ||
| Rick Rainey | Doc's Panthers | K | 1983 | ||
| Greg Reed | Cincinnati Jets | WR | 1983 | ||
| John McIntosh | Doc's Panthers | QB | 1983 | ||
| Kenny Taylor | Cincinnati Jets | OLB | 1984 | ||
| Phil Eakins | Cincinnati Jets | QB | 1984 | ||
| Larry Marshall | Doc's Panthers | FS | 1984 | ||
| Gary Brown | Doc's Panthers | OL | 1984 | ||
| Mike Slaughter | Tri-City Cats | TE | 1984 | ||
| Hank Orso | Cincinnati Jets | MLB | 1984 | ||
| Charlie Raymond | Pin-haus Strikers | DE | 1985 | ||
| Randy Williams | Cincinnati Jets | SS | 1985 | ||
| Maurice Green | Doc's Panthers | LB | 1985 | ||
| Mike Harris | Cincinnati Jets | LB | 1985 | ||
| Brian Thomas | Pin-haus Strikers | MLB | 1986 | ||
| John Hoeh | Pin-haus Strikers | DE | 1986 | ||
| Kurt Tucker | Cincinnati Jets | QB | 1986 | ||
| Russell Cooper | Cincinnati Jets | RB | 1987 | ||
| Gene Smith | Cincinnati Jets | MLB | 1987 | ||
| Paul Rapking | Pin-haus Strikers | K | 1988 | ||
| Joe Hoeh | Pin-haus Strikers | FS | 1988 | ||
| Shawn Hocker | Kentucky Raiders | DE | 1989 | ||
| Darryl Brockman | Cincinnati Jets | TE | 1989 | ||
| Jamel Cooper | Cincinnati Vikings | QB | 1990 | ||
| Tony Jones | Cincinnati Vikings | DE | 1990 | ||
| Jack Hoeh | Pin-haus Strikers | WR | 1990 | ||
| Dave Guidugli | Kentucky Raiders | DE | 1990 | ||
| Stan Thomas | Cincinnati Vikings | RB | 1990 | ||
| Toby Jones | Silver Coach Cowboys | SS | 1991 | ||
| John Hollingsworth | Silver Coach Cowboys | QB | 1991 | ||
| Larry Bruins | Pin-haus Strikers | CB | 1991 | ||
| Darryl Williams | Silver Coach Cowboys | WR | 1991 | ||
| Anthony Jamison | Silver Coach Cowboys | OL | 1992 | ||
| Shawn Johns | Cincinnati Falcons | RB | 1992 | ||
| Mike Beasley | Cincinnati Falcons | WR | 1992 | ||
| Dwayne Reed | Kentucky Raiders | OT | 1992 | ||
| Jeff Love | Kentucky Raiders | CB | 1992 | ||
| Terry McQuien | NKY Raiders | FS | 1993 | ||
| Wendell Whitehead | Cincinnati Falcons | WR | 1993 | ||
| Derek Vaughn | Silver Coach Cowboys | OLB | 1994 | ||
| Sean Clark | Cincinnati Falcons | OL | 1994 | ||
| Mike Metzger | Silver Coach Cowboys | FB | 1994 | ||
| Shawn Middlebrook | Kentucky Raiders | DE | 1995 | ||
| William Nintrump | Cincinnati Chargers | C | 1995 | ||
| Mike Ward | Goshen Redskins | FS | 1995 | ||
| Kenny Ward | NKY Raiders | HB | 1996 | ||
| Sam Clay | Kentucky Raiders | RB | 1996 | ||
| AC Reed | Cincinnati Jaguars | FS | 1997 | ||
| Howard Tidwell | Kentucky Raiders | QB | 1997 | ||
| Tony Bray | Cincinnati Dolphins | RB | 1997 | ||
| Homer Reeves | Cincinnati Dolphins | C | 1997 | ||
| Andre Crockett | Cincinnati Jaguars | WR | 1997 | ||
| Brian Wells | Kings Comets | OL | 1998 | ||
| Darnell Latham | Cincinnati Jets | RB | 1998 | ||
| Emmanuel Graham | Cincinnati Panthers | WR | 1999 | ||
| Larry Byndon | Kentucky Stallions | RB | 1999 | ||
| Rob Bouldin | Kentucky Stallions | FB | 1999 | ||
| Darryl Moore | Cincinnati Heat | WR | 2000 | ||
| Sean Solomon | Ohio Browns | DE | 2000 | ||
| Lance Dolby | Ohio Browns | MLB | 2000 | ||
| Dante Horton | Cincinnati Heat | RB | 2000 | ||
| Brian Harris | Ohio Browns | RB | 2001 | ||
| Larry Turney | Cincinnati Heat | DE | 2001 | ||
| Demetrius Howard | Ohio Browns | LB | 2001 | ||
| Jesse O | Cincinnati Ravens | OL | 2001 | ||
| Ralph Caves | Ohio Patriots | DE | 2003 | ||
| Andre Scott | Cincinnati Playboyz | LB | 2004 | ||
| Keth Brooks | Kings Comets | RB | 2004 | ||
| Kil Goins | Cincinnati Playboyz | SS | 2004 | ||
| Stan West | Kings Comets | DT | 2005 | ||
| Greg Hellums | Kings Comets | WR | 2005 | ||
| Anthony Tyus | Kings Comets | WR | 2005 | ||
| Donald Smith | Cincinnati Gamblers | OL | 2005 | ||
| LeNeil White | Cincinnati Gamblers | MLB | 2007 | ||
| Terry Stuckey | KY/OH Xtreme | DT | 2007 | ||
| Derrick Hall | Silver Coach Cowboys | LB | 2010 | ||
| Travis Johnson | Kings Comets | K/P | 2010 | ||
| Mitch Robinson | Cincinnati Falcons | LB | 2010 | ||
| Dwayne Edwards | NKY Raiders | DB | 2010 | ||
| Lamont Springs | Cincinnati Falcons | OL | 2010 | ||
| Dewayne Reed | NKY Raiders | Coach | 2010 | ||
| Bob Sager Sr. | Admin/Support | A/S | 2010 | ||
| Bob Sager Jr. | Admin/Support | A/S | 2010 | ||
| John Sager | Admin/Support | A/S | 2010 | ||
| Calvin Pettit | Silver Coach Cowboys | OL | 2010 | ||
| Terry Clark | NKY Raiders | DL | 2010 | ||
| Bud Clemons | Pin-haus Strikers | Coach | 2010 | ||
| Jay Campbell | Cincinnati Heat | Coach | 2010 | ||